A global initiative to accelerate reform of security organisations.

What we are

Fiber_optic2

Background

In June 2014 – one year after the first revelations by Edward Snowden – privacy veteran Simon Davies published a report on the tangible impact of those disclosures on legislation and public opinion http://www.privacysurgeon.org/blog/wp-content/uploads/2014/06/Snowden-final-report-for-publication.pdf . The report, featuring contributions from 42 experts across the world, concluded that only a handful of governments had responded to the disclosures in any meaningful way (reform efforts in the US were prominent). Most countries had either ignored the Snowden material or had responded with a mix of obfuscation and denial.

Importantly, the report also discovered that media coverage of the Snowden material was absent in most countries. It had become primarily an Anglo-American issue, with the notable exception of extensive German press coverage. Even EU countries such as Italy barely reported the disclosures, evidenced by a straw poll of university students in Rome, sixty percent of whom had not heard of Snowden.

Prospects for national security reform (legal compliance, transparency, accountability etc) since the publication of the report have deteriorated further. Commitments to reform in the US appear to have stalled, while the outgoing head of GCHQ gave a farewell speech in October 2014 that essentially denied the substance of the revelations. Meanwhile, countries such as Australia, Canada, France, Denmark and Spain have responded to heightened terrorist threats with security legislation that could best be described as draconian.

The birth of Code Red

The report’s findings sparked substantial dialogue within civil society about the need for a more strategic approach to international reform activity. There was general agreement that the answer lies beyond conventional funding for legal cases. One of the most critically important needs was to build stronger bridges between the technical, legal, whistleblower, media and the policy worlds. Currently, relatively few people straddle these dimensions and information and cooperation between those spheres is patchy. A second need is to find a way to make information on reform activities much more accessible and useful through a clearinghouse utility. Finally, improved strategic and tactical advice was needed by reform campaigners.

This discussion solidified into an initiative called “Code Red”. Its 35-member advisory group contains a wide spectrum of prominent and experienced campaigners, legal and security experts and whistleblowers including Tor’s Jacob Appelbaum, former NSA technical director William Binney, crypto pioneer Whitfield Diffie and security guru Bruce Schneier. The project is led by Simon Davies – father of the international privacy activist movement, and Annie Machon – former MI5 intelligence officer turned whistleblower,

Stakeholder assessment

Currently reform activity is principally focused on two activities. The first of these is legal work (notably NGO’s such as Privacy International, EFF and Privacy First). The second principal focus is technology solutions (crypto and circumvention innovation by technologists such as those in CCC and C-Base). There is also a considerable amount of privacy activity at the corporate and start-up level. More general campaigning is being conducted by around two hundred privacy organisations.

Code Red does not intend to replicate the work of these organisations. Its aim is to provide new information and cooperative conduits between them to enhance the integrity and effectiveness of their activities.

Development stages

The conceptual and evidentiary stages of Code Red have been completed.  Considerable work has been achieved in outreach and consultation, including public meetings in Amsterdam, Copenhagen, Brussels, Vienna and Rome. The advisory group has been appointed and volunteer staff are being recruited.

The organisation is now approaching the launch phase. The launch is being staggered across several events, including the International Journalism Festival in Perugia and C-Base in Berlin. A website has been commissioned and this will be operational in April 2015.

“The next immediate step for Code Red will be infrastructure development, including creation of a legal entity, financial arrangements and an appropriate governance structure. Over this period funding will be sought to build the organisation. It is likely that in the short term a trusted NGO will be selected to manage initial funding.”